‘The Sandman’ Netflix Assessment: Neil Gaiman’s Comedian Will get TV Adaptation

As a newcomer to Neil Gaiman’s seminal comedian e-book collection “The Sandman” (cue diehard followers instantly clicking out of this assessment, and truthful sufficient!), I got here to Netflix’s adaptation with an open thoughts and curious eye. Realizing this 1989 title had spawned onscreen spinoffs of “Sandman” characters — “Lucifer,” “Constantine,” etcetera — however by no means considered one of its personal, it was arduous to not surprise what about it may need made a live-action model so arduous that it by no means occurred till now. As I went backwards and forwards between the TV present and the unique volumes, although, the issue that any manufacturing would have in tackling its scope turned clearer — and made Netflix’s consequence extra spectacular, too.

As tailored by Gaiman, Allan Heinberg (“Surprise Lady”), and David S. Goyer (“Constantine,” “Basis”), TV’s “The Sandman” errs towards a literal translation of the comics as usually as potential. For as advanced because the collection’ mythology turns into, the present finds a strategy to introduce new followers with out fully complicated them. All it has to do to convey us on top of things is clarify that The Sandman (aka Dream, performed with gravel-voiced gravitas by Tom Sturridge) is considered one of a number of siblings who rule essential facets of humanity, from Dream, to Dying (Kirby Howell-Baptiste), to the twins of Need (Mason Alexander Park) and Despair (Donna Preston). From there, you’re both in otherwise you’re out, and off it goes.

Every of the season’s 10 episodes are likely to faithfully correspond to particular comedian points, from the opening saga (“Sleep of the Simply”) of how Dream received captured by a nefarious novice magician (Charles Dance, good as ever to make an instantly sinister impression), to Dream confronting a defiant vortex that threatens to swallow his realm for good (“Misplaced Hearts”). Some episodes transpose Gaiman’s traces phrase for phrase, together with “The Sound of Her Wings,” which introduces Howell-Baptiste as an particularly magnetic, heat model of Dying. Others increase and flesh out a difficulty’s preliminary concepts, equivalent to one deeply disturbing chapter (“24/7”) through which an escaped psychiatric affected person (portrayed with completely unnerving precision by David Thewlis) turns a relaxation cease diner into his personal private morality experiment.

There are, as was inevitable, a few exceptions to the “one concern equals one episode” rule. For one, the season excludes flashback quantity “Tales within the Sand” fully, which frankly could also be for the very best. For an additional, the TV present threads your complete season with the lurking risk of “The Corinthian,” a vicious rogue nightmare performed by Boyd Holbrook with a chilling, silken smirk. But when any diehards have made it this far within the assessment, relaxation assured: Netflix’s “The Sandman” hews unusually near its supply materials by way of content material. The place it diverges most, then, is in its casting and visuals — considered one of which proves a direct enchancment, whereas the opposite finally ends up a disappointment.

As Dream, Sturridge can’t do an entire lot past what’s requested of him (i.e. embody an extremely self-serious immortal being with out making him unbearable), which he does admirably sufficient. However one of many smartest facets of Gaiman’s preliminary method to sketching out the collection’ huge mythos is that the story weaves in loads of different foremost characters for the viewers to latch onto when Dream is just too busy moping to be compelling. What’s extra: in one of the crucial apparent and welcome adjustments from web page to display screen, lots of them are now not such comparable white blondes, both. In addition to Howell-Baptiste’s Dying, who started as a peppy emo lady within the comics, there’s Hell’s guardian Lucifer, now performed by “Recreation of Thrones” standout Gwendoline Christie. Dream’s trustworthy librarian goes from Lucien to Lucienne (a steady-eyed Vivian Acheampong). Cockney demon hunter John Constantine, who’s had loads of TV illustration already, reveals up right here as Johanna (a refreshingly unleashed Jenna Coleman). All informed, and to its credit score, the onscreen “Sandman” fortunately features a far broader swath of individuals and backgrounds than its supply materials.

It could be tempting to say the present much less monochromatic than the comedian, if solely that held true for its aesthetic. The unique illustrations — first formed by Sam Kieth, Mike Dringenberg and Malcolm Jones III with colorist Daniel Vozzo — matched Gaiman’s stark phrases with equally distinct pictures of formidable gods, twisted realities clashing with dream worlds, and the surprising viscera of violence. It’s all the time asking so much for an onscreen adaptation of a comic book to match its inspiration, however Netflix’s model not often captures the identical visible spirit outdoors of, maybe, “24/7,” directed by Jamie Childs. In any other case, Dream and his cohorts too usually get misplaced in dingy darkness or vast, muddy CGI landscapes that ring too false to be actually engrossing. Even Lucifer’s black feathered wings can’t match the majesty of those rendered in pen and paper with veins and the stretched leather-based of unfathomable age. That “The Sandman” finally ends up trying an entire lot like Netflix’s variations of “Locke and Key” or “Shadow and Bone” is exceptional, contemplating how wildly totally different Gaiman’s self-consciously gritty comedian is from these YA fantasy novels.

Nonetheless: the present works arduous to set itself other than these Netflix makes an attempt at reanimating beloved properties that as a substitute flattened them out. Most notable — not less than from this exhausted TV critic’s perspective — is that the season metes out its materials with a cost-effective method (no episode runs over 54 minutes) and sensible narrative construction. Although The Corinthian looms massive all through, the primary a number of episodes ship Dream on a hunt all through the waking world for his beloved “instruments,” which acts as a helpful introduction to his powers and perspective in the direction of his human topics; behind the season, the present shifts in the direction of explaining Dream’s siblings and precarious place amongst them because the clock ticks all the way down to a possible disaster. With sufficient forward-facing momentum and the may of Gaiman’s ever-complicating lore behind, Netflix’s “The Sandman” justifies its existence — and the potential for a lot extra story to come back — time and time once more.

“The Sandman” is now accessible to stream on Netflix.